The St Helena Government (SHG) has published the findings of its public consultation on the Future of the Fishing Industry, which show broad agreement on what the industry should achieve. Local fish supply, infrastructure and environmental protection emerged as the strongest themes.

The consultation ran from September to October 2026 and received 19 individual and group responses from fishers, industry representatives, councillors, organisations and members of the public. It sought views on a range of policy options rather than asking people to vote for a preferred solution.

Most respondents want a fishing industry that is environmentally sustainable and economically viable, provides jobs and livelihoods, supplies local people with fish and contributes to the wider economy. Differences of opinion were mainly about how to reach these goals, not about the goals themselves.

Key findings

  • Local supply comes first. The strongest message was the importance of affordable fish for the local community, which respondents linked to food security, health and community wellbeing.
  • Exports divided opinion. Some respondents saw potential in niche export markets that promote St Helena’s sustainable one-by-one fishing methods. Others highlighted freight and energy costs, market access and past difficulties. The consultation concluded that exports should not be ruled out, but that their commercial viability needs further assessment.
  • Infrastructure is a clear priority. There was strong agreement on the need to improve ice production, cold storage, fish landing, processing and harbour facilities, with many believing this would benefit the industry whichever policy direction is chosen.
  • Trust and communication need attention. Respondents raised concerns about fisheries management, decision-making, scientific evidence, fish processing arrangements and communication. They recognised that improving trust and transparency will be important to the industry’s success.
  • Better collaboration, not new structures. There was support for reviewing institutional arrangements and improving leadership, accountability and coordination, but respondents were more interested in organisations working better together than in creating new bodies.
  • Environmental protections have strong support. Most respondents supported continued participation in the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT), retaining the Marine Protected Area (MPA) and continuing one-by-one fishing. There was very little support for withdrawing from ICCAT, revoking MPA status or introducing mini-spool long-line fishing.
  • The workforce is ageing. Respondents want more done to attract younger people into fishing, while noting that recruitment depends on the industry remaining economically viable and attractive.

The consultation did not point to a single model for the industry’s future. Instead, it showed support for practical improvements and collaboration over more radical changes to fisheries management arrangements.

The findings will inform the finalisation of Future of the Fishing Industry: Options for Policy. The Minister for Environment, Natural Resources and Planning, Karl Thrower, will consider the options and present a final policy recommendation to Executive Council. New policy is expected to be in place by the end of March 2027.

#StHelena #Fisheries #ConsultationFeedback

www.facebook.com/StHelenaGovt